Top 5 Must-Watch Paramount+ Shows This Week: December 15–19, 2025

Looking for the best shows to binge on Paramount+ this week? Screen Rant has you covered with 5 expert streaming picks – all Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes and perfect additions to your watchlist.

The top 5 must-watch Paramount+ shows this week, December 15–19, 2025, include critically acclaimed series, viral trending hits, and fan-favorite hidden gems. #1 is considered by many to be a flawless 10/10 masterpiece.

Don’t forget – Screen Rant drops official weekly streaming guides for Netflix, Prime Video, Apple TV, and HBO Max every Monday. Discover the most addictive bingeable shows to stream only on Paramount+ right now.

Broad City

Logline: “Broad City follows two women throughout their daily lives in New York City, making the smallest and mundane events hysterical and disturbing to watch all at the same time.”

As a Paramount+ subscriber, you not only have access to the top streaming Taylor Sheridan series, but you also have access to a vault of Comedy Central modern masterpieces. One of these all-time comedy hits is Broad City, a celebrated series that some may consider to be the definitive buddy comedy for the millennial generation.

Created by and starring Ilana Glazer and Abbi Jacobson, the critically acclaimed series – which earned a near-perfect 99% Rotten Tomatoes score – also gave rise to comedic talents Hannibal Buress and Paul W. Downs. If you’re looking for guaranteed laughs with a modern classic 2010s edge this week, all five seasons of Broad City are perfect to binge.

The Agency

Logline: “A covert CIA agent is ordered to abandon his undercover life and return to his Station; when the love he left behind reappears, romance reignites.”

The Agency, recently renamed to The Agency: Central Intelligence, is one of the most acclaimed yet overlooked political drama series streaming on Paramount+ right now. The Agency earned a solid 77% Rotten Tomatoes audience score for its first season, which premiered back in 2024.

Entrenched in CIA espionage, The Agency features a fantastic ensemble cast led by Michael Fassbender, Jeffrey Wright, John Magaro, Jodie Turner-Smith, Richard Gere, and more. With a second season already confirmed by Paramount, spy thriller fans won’t want to miss this sophisticated and epic 10-part series.

House Of Lies

Logline: “A charming management consultant and his crack team use every dirty trick in the book to woo powerful CEOs and close huge deals.”

As a Paramount+ subscriber, you have access to most of Showtime’s vault of acclaimed series, such as the Emmy-winning financial dramedy House of Lies. Starring Don Cheadle and Kristen Bell, this beloved show ran for five seasons, consisting of 58 immersive and surprisingly funny episodes.

If you’re looking for a Certified Fresh series to binge this week with a modern classic feel straight out of the early 2010s, House of Lies is one of the best streaming options for you. It’s already guaranteed fan-approved with a Rotten Tomatoes audience score of 84%, ensuring you won’t be wasting your time by diving in this week.

Mayor Of Kingstown

Logline: “The McLusky family are power brokers tackling themes of systemic racism, corruption and inequality in Kingstown, Michigan, where the business of incarceration is the only thriving industry.”

As Landman dominates Paramount+’s streaming charts in the U.S., Mayor of Kingstown is quietly making a case as the best crime drama series on streaming right now – and maybe even of 2025. Co-created by Taylor Sheridan and executive-produced by Dave Erickson (Sons of Anarchy), this series has somehow elevated itself above its past installments with a masterful season 4.

Starring Jeremy Renner of massive MCU acclaim, this is one dark, even relentless, crime drama, which is part of the reason why it’s become must-see TV. Currently 8 episodes into its 10-part fourth season, Mayor of Kingstown is a fantastic binge-watching option this week, especially if you want to catch up in time for its season 4 finale on December 29.

Fellow Travelers

Logline: “Decades-long chronicle of the risky, volatile and steamy relationship between the charismatic and ambitious Hawk and the pious and idealistic Tim, two political staffers who fall in love at the height of the 1950s Lavender Scare.”

Fellow Travelers feels like it came and went far too soon without the proper recognition it deserved. Based on a bestselling novel, the series explores the relationship between two men that spans decades, backdropped by political and societal condemnation for LGBTQ+ persons during the latter half of 20th-century America.

Led by outstanding, and perhaps career-best, performances by Matt Bomer and Jonathan Bailey, Fellow Travelers earned a 90% Rotten Tomatoes score from critics and audiences alike, and was nominated for 3 Emmys, including Lead and Supporting Actor for Bomer and Bailey. At 8 episodes, this is truly one of the very best shows you can binge this week on Paramount+.

Looking For More Streaming Options This Week?

Check out Screen Rant’s binge-watching guides for last weekend’s top shows.