Why Netflix’s ‘The Electric State’ Was So Divisive

Netflix‘s latest sci-fi epic, The Electric State, made its debut on March 14, 2025. Having risen to the top of Netflix’s charts since then, and then dropping to the #6 spot, the movie has become one of the most talked-about films in recent times, not just for The Electric State‘s ambitious storyline but also for how it has polarized critics and audiences. Despite the film’s ranking on Netflix’s global charts, its Rotten Tomatoes scores tell a different story — a meager 15% critic score against a solid 71% audience rating. The drastic divide between critics and audiences has given way to debate over the film’s merits and flaws.

Directed by the Russo brothers, The Electric State was one of Netflix’s most expensive projects, with a reported production budget of $320 million. The film, blending the aftermath of a world overtaken by technology with a deeply emotional journey, is a visually stunning adaptation of Simon Stålenhag’s graphic novel. However, critics and audiences remain divided in their reception of the film, with the former bashing the film’s reliance on AI, lackluster performances, and bloated budget, while viewers have credited the film for its action sequences, immersive world-building, and emotional storytelling.

Read Our Review

Critics Have Slammed ‘The Electric State’ for Its Use of AI

One of the primary points of contention surrounding The Electric State is its heavy reliance on AI. Critics argue that, despite the film’s visually stunning graphics, it lacks the human touch that makes a piece of work truly resonate with viewers. With the massive budget that the film boasts, critics have questioned whether the investment is justified, with many believing that the outcome does not justify the scale of spending. Bashing the movie for its use of AI, Calum Cooper of Flick Feast said:

“The Electric State is ugly, artificial content constructed by algorithms over sincerity, designed for bored consumers to slap on in the background instead of engaging with fun or rewarding cinema. The Russo brothers should be ashamed of themselves.”

In an interview with The Times, Joe Russo confirmed that AI was used in the post-production process of The Electric State. The director admitted that while AI is still developing and cannot be used for critical work, it remains a useful tool in filmmaking. Amidst backlash from critics, the Russo brothers have defended their decision to use AI in The Electric State, admitting that artists must remain in control of the tool despite its potential benefits. As per Anthony Russo:

“We have to approach AI the same way we approach all technological innovations. It’s potentially a valuable tool, but it’s the kind of tool that artists always have to remain in control of, but there’s going to be some valuable role in the creative process and the filmmaking process.”

Viewers Love the Emotion and Immersive Plot of ‘The Electric State’

The critical backlash that The Electric State has received has not deterred the enthusiastic reaction of audiences. A majority of viewers have been appreciative of the thrilling retro-futuristic adventure that the film brings to screens. The 71% rating on Rotten Tomatoes also suggests that viewers see the movie in a highly different light than critics. Rather than focusing on the film’s use of AI and budget, viewers have chosen to zero in on The Electric State‘s emotionally driven storytelling and stunning world-building.

One of The Electric State‘s strongest aspects is the film’s ability to not only transport viewers but also immerse them in a world that is reeling from the war between humans and robots. The landscape of the film is eerily haunting, filled with giant mechanical creatures and breathtaking visual effects. Although critics view the film’s use of AI as a flaw, fans argue that the technology has allowed The Electric State to deliver an engaging, unique, and immersive watch. Awarding the film an “A+,” Justin H said:

“I often find that if the critics hate it, the audience it’s designed for will love it. This is perfect escapism, what a fun and well done movie. This was such a fun watch. It was a great way to redo end rethink the 90s and all the touches and characters were so great. Thank you Netflix! Millie was great in this. Same with Chris. A+”

Has the Russo Brothers’ Vision of ‘The Electric State’ Been a Hit or Miss?

Anthony and Joe Russo have built a steady reputation for delivering high-stakes and action-packed watches. Having helmed some of Marvel’s biggest hits, including Avengers: Infinity War (2018), Captain America: Civil War (2016), Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014), and Avengers: Endgame (2019), the directors have now transitioned into Netflix products. However, The Electric State has proven to be one of their most polarizing projects yet, with the film being referred to as the worst of the directors’ careers.

The Electric State‘s premise, a retro-futuristic world where a young girl sets out on a mission to locate her missing brother, accompanied by a robot who has her brother’s consciousness embedded within it, had enough potential to be a deeply moving sci-fi adventure. Yet, critics argue that the Russo brothers’ execution fell flat, lacking “the subtlety and nuance to resonate beyond the elaborate set pieces.”

Related

Despite ‘The Electric State’s Awful Rotten Tomatoes Score, Netflix’s New Blockbuster Is Clearly Setting Up a Franchise

A Rotten Tomatoes score is not about to deter Netflix’s latest high-budget movie, ‘The Electric State.’

However, preventing the film from being a total miss, viewers appreciate the Russo brothers’ vision, particularly the directors’ ability to craft a visually engaging, emotional narrative. Although fans agree that the premise and execution of the film are not particularly groundbreaking or award-worthy, viewers do credit the movie for being better than critical reviews. The film is fun and entertaining, with heartfelt themes and background stories that are simple yet enjoyable. Viewing The Electric State in this light, one might be able to contend that the Russo brothers’ vision of The Electric State has been a hit. The Electric State is now available to stream on Netflix.