School year or calendar year? US age-group soccer’s growing up pains

December 5 – MLS NEXT has been compelled to look at its age-group structure, and it feels like another uniquely American moment in a sport that’s forever trying to balance global standards with local habits. 

Beginning in the 2026-27 season, the Allstate Homegrown Division will stick with the traditional birth-year system that runs January to December, and has been in place since 2017, while the Academy Division shifts to a school-year format running August to July. Begging the question as to why is the United States still so hesitant to fully commit to the birth-year model the rest of the world uses?

The Homegrown Division staying on birth-year is logical. It lines up with FIFA, matches every major international competition, and cleans up the pathway for youth national teams. Coaches know exactly what they’re working with, scouts can compare like-for-like, and players grow up in the same rhythm as their peers abroad.

But the Academy Division moving to a school-year timeline tells its own story about American youth soccer. Culturally, the school calendar still drives everything from club schedules to family planning. MLS NEXT is trying to meet that reality halfway. The league says the shift will help it line up with the wider youth landscape, build relationships with more clubs, and keep the talent pipeline flowing. It’s an understandable move, but it sits awkwardly next to the very standards the league claims it wants to mirror.

Development thrives on clarity. If a player is born in December, their pathway looks different depending on which division they’re in. That kind of inconsistency doesn’t exist abroad. For a country trying to catch up with the world’s best, these small gaps in structure become big gaps in development.

League officials spoke with academy directors, youth leaders, national team staff, and club operators across every corner of the system to get buy-in.

Still, at some point, the United States has to decide whether it wants to keep operating on two calendars or finally join the rest of the football world on one. Until then, questions about consistency, scouting, and long-term growth aren’t going anywhere.

Contact the writer of this story at moc.l1764910918labto1764910918ofdlr1764910918owedi1764910918sni@r1764910918etsbe1764910918w.kci1764910918n1764910918